Subscription Billing Vs Recurring Billing: What You Need to Know?

Unable to choose between subscription billing and recurring billing?

Getting confused with the related concepts of subscription and recurring billing while deciding on your pricing strategy?

Not surprising. Many businesses having multi-period billing and payment structures are facing the same concern.

Is a subscription a recurring payment?

This question is buzzing around the market among businesses like food and catering, SaaS providers, and fitness providers.

While subscription billing and recurring billing are terms used interchangeably, both have distinct differences in their model that you as a business need to know.

This blog will cover everything related to subscription billing vs recurring billing to help you make an informed decision.

Here are the things you will learn from this blog:

  • What are recurring billing and subscription billing? (with examples)
  • Subscription billing vs recurring billing: mapping the differences
  • Which is the best payment structure for your business?

So, are you ready? Let’s start right away.

What is Subscription Billing? (+2 Examples)

Subscription billing is an automated payment collection system that starts after the customer signs up to access or use a product/service.

The key information areas of subscription systems include the following:

  • Subscription Start Date (the date of the first subscription billing)
  • Duration or Frequency (how often payments happen or the length of the billing cycle such as 1 month, 3 months, and 12 months)
  • Amount to be Charged (the charges for the service/product/feature based on the billing cycle)

Subscription billing is a type of recurring payment model that offers flexible pricing and billing options. In this billing and payment method, the different offerings of the business are divided into several flexible programs or plans providing custom pricing models to customers. This helps businesses earn more customers and create long relationships.

The plans and programs include free trials, easy upgrades and downgrades of the subscription plan, and more affordable payment solutions.

Examples of Businesses Leveraging Subscription Billing

  • Amazon Prime

    This is probably among the best-known brands leveraging the subscription system of billing and payments with as many as 40 million subscribers. The subscription program of Amazon Prime is making a difference due to its wide range of features and benefits offered for monthly, quarterly, or annual plans.

    For instance, when you subscribe to Amazon Prime for a 1 month or 3-month plan, you get free two days shipping for all kinds of orders, access to unlimited prime movies and videos, access to a lot of prime music, unlimited photo storage, and access to read unlimited books on Kindle.

    What more can a customer ask for? It’s enough awesomeness to make the customer think that they are enrolling for a killer deal.

  • Dollar Shave Club

    This is yet another brand that has nailed it when it comes to leveraging the subscription business model. Dollar Shave Club has created a subscription program using shaving products and earned the highest customer retention rate among grooming businesses.

    They could penetrate the market because of their unique approach and the direct benefits to their customer base. With just a small amount paid every month, customers can get a brand-new razor and shaving swag mailed to their doorstep. Doesn’t that sound great?

Now, let’s understand the concept of recurring billing.

What is Recurring Billing? (+ Example)

A recurring billing model refers to scheduled, periodic, and repeated automated collection of payments from customers for subscription services or products. With this model in place, you collect payments and keep charging customers credit/debit cards at regular intervals for the agreed-upon cost with the help of a payment processor. There are several issues faced in recurring billing but they can be easily managed with an efficient processor or software like Square and FacilePay.

The recurring payment system follows a model that involves customers and merchants engaging in an ongoing relationship. This model does not involve the flexibility like easy cancellations and custom feature plans.

For example:

Customers don’t sign up for the recurring fee paid for utility services including electricity and water. The fee paid for utility services are a part of customers’ daily lifecycle and recurring payments make it feasible for them to manage those transactions monthly or quarterly. Recurring payment truthfully and promptly bills each customer, taking into account the taxes, proration, and missed payments.

The two types of recurring billing systems include the following:

  • Fixed Recurring Billing: In this model, a fixed amount is always debited from customers’ bank accounts on every scheduled date for the used products/services.
  • Variable Recurring Billing: In this model, the amount to be charged will be usage-based and so vary with each billing cycle.

The majority of subscription businesses fall under the recurring billing system, namely, Dropbox (saas industry), Practo (health & fitness sector), and Udemy (education and e-learning industry).

#Retrospection-Point: Businesses using the recurring billing system are also using a subscription payment model. Like, Dropbox is one of the successful businesses leveraging the recurring billing system while also falling under the category of subscription model. Why?

You may have till now noted several similarities between the two structures and figured out the differences meanwhile.

No more guessing. The below section on subscription billing vs recurring billing will give you a clear idea of the differences. Let’s dive in right away.

Subscription Billing Vs Recurring Billing: Mapping the 3 Differences Based on Pricing Plans

S.No Recurring Billing Subscription Billing
1.

Usage-based billing

Customers are charged based on their service or product usage on a predetermined or fixed schedule.

Freemiums

Free access to a limited set of features are provided to customers signing up with an easy option to upgrade with a paid membership plan with no risks.

2.

User-based billing

Payment cycle is typically based on the number of users accessing a product/service.

Example: SaaS products.

Promotion-to-Subscription Model or Try-Before-You-Buy Model

Free access for a limited time period is allowed to customers signing up before they automatically get upgraded to a paid membership plan. Customers will have to pay if they wish to continue using the product/service.

3.

Tiered billing

Customers are billed based on the feature package they choose. The pricing for the feature packages are created on a tier-based format having the need to upgrade to a higher plan for access to more utilities.

Overage Subscriptions or Hybrid Pricing

Customers get access to a set of features with a base fee structure with option to upgrade to higher plans having more benefitting utilities in it. Users can easily upgrade as well as downgrade if the higher plans don’t fit them for the long run. However, the base fee will be constantly charged that includes the basic features.

Subscription Billing Vs Recurring Billing: 3 Core Differences Based on the Billing Approach

Both subscription billing and recurring billing can be seen crossing each other’s path at various levels. The above definitions, business examples, and pricing structures are a clear walk through to understand their points of intersection. These intersection points often create confusion for businesses when deciding on their pricing strategy. To clear the air, let’s have a precise look into their differences.

  • Signing-up for the Feature Usage: In recurring billing, customers don’t necessarily need to sign up for the services like in case of electricity and water. On the other hand, subscription billing requires the customer to sign up for a particular pricing structure for a set of features.
  • Flexibility in Billing Process: Subscription billing offers the flexibility to upgrade, downgrade, and even cancel the paid membership plans anytime. On the other hand, recurring billing doesn’t offer much flexibility and is often referred to as payment structure with no deadline or end date like for health insurance plans.
  • Approach to Recurring Revenue: Subscription billing model is a structure that aims to penetrate the market with a strategic payment structure. On the other hand, the recurring billing model tries to streamline the revenue cycle and brings convenience and cost-effectiveness.

You can see while both are interlinked, they have distinct qualities making them different in terms of features. Let’s understand in which scenarios you can choose subscription billing.

When to Choose Subscription Billing?

You can choose subscription billing for the product or service of your business, if you want to:

  • Penetrate the market with a unique preposition that helps to overcome the prevailing high prices
  • Enhance the convenience for customers in terms of the process to make payments as well as a flexible approach with pricing and transaction module
  • Strategically boost your scope of revenue by the use of pricing and payments structure such as free trial subscription packages

Therefore, subscription billing works best for businesses that have a product/service with a customizable pricing structure to penetrate the market, boost revenue and profit, and ultimately grow. Since you know about recurring billing, let’s understand when you can choose recurring billing for your business.

When to Choose Recurring Billing?

You can choose recurring billing for the product or service of your business, if you want to:

  • Streamline the revenue cycle of your business with a predictable and steady cash flow
  • Better manage billing and payment cycles
  • Create a plan-to-action for churns through efficient monitoring
  • Improve the overall process with control over errors
  • Cut down on transaction costs

In simple terms, recurring billing is the best choice for businesses that want a more managed billing and payments structure to enhance the accounts-related processes. Configuring recurring payments on Squarespace or WordPress is very easy. You don’t have to spend a lot of time to get started with this payment structure.

Which is the Best?

The answer lies in your business model, your existing customers, and what you wanted to achieve with your pricing strategy. There can’t be a one-size-fit-all pricing structure for every business.

When weighing up your options, evaluate your customer expectations, your products/services lifespan such as whether it lasts a month, a year, or forever, and your revenue as well as growth expectation.

Let’s now have some common queries answered on subscription billing and recurring billing from below.

Frequently Asked Questions About Subscription Billings Vs Recurring Billing

  1. Is it possible for a business to incorporate both the pricing structures?

    Yes. It is possible for a business to use both the pricing structures. However, as a business you should always make a thorough evaluation on whether your offered services/products blend naturally into both these pricing modules or not.

    Key points to make this evaluation are stated below:

    • Lifespan of your products/services (whether it lasts for 1 month, 2 months, 3 months, 6 months, 12 months, or forever)
    • Features of your products/services (whether your service or product naturally fits recurring or subscription models)
    • Revenue & expenditure position (Whether your business needs to have lump sum amounts to manage its expenses or work best with recurring revenue)
  2. Which softwares to use for recurring and subscription billing?

    There are many softwares in the market that work for subscription and recurring payments. Some of them are mentioned below.

    • Square
    • FacilePay
    • ChargeOver
    • Zoho Subscriptions
    • Freshbooks
  3. Does it take a lot of time to integrate recurring and subscription billing systems?

    The time needed to integrate recurring and subscription billing systems depend on the type of software or payment processor used. However, if you are using a payment processor or software mentioned in the above answer, there won’t be much time involved with the integration or set-up.

Ready to Get Started with Recurring Billing or Subscription Billing?

In this blog, you have learned about the differences of recurring and subscription billing with a closer look into the ways both the modules intersect at certain points. There are benefits associated with both the models. As a business, it depends on your objectives and how you plan your pricing strategy.

Whether the recurring billing process or the subscription billing system, FacilePay can help you with both the pricing structures. Consider using it to leverage the maximum from these pricing modules.

Rakesh-patel

Written by

Rakesh Patel

Rakesh Patel is the Founder and CEO of Facilepay Technology. He has 28 years of IT experience in business strategies, operations and information technology. He has expertise in various aspects of business like project planning, sales, and marketing, and has successfully defined flawless business models for the clients. A techie by mind and a writer at heart, he has authored two books – Enterprise Mobility: Strategy and Solutions and A Guide To Open311.

Related Blogs

Benefits of Recurring Payments

7 Benefits of Recurring Payments: Things Subscription Businesses Should Leverage

Are you distressed with a heavy churn rate? Do you want to optimize your revenue operations? Check out the benefits of recurring payments.

What are Recurring Payments

What are Recurring Payments? [A Complete Guide]

Do you look for an efficient solution to manage your subscription payments and billing cycles? Learn what are recurring payments and how they can help you.

Steps to Accept Recurring Payments

5 Easy Steps to Accept Recurring Payments Online (+Examples of Best Processors to Use)

Want to accept recurring payments online (via direct debits)? Looking for the best payment processors to use? Read this blog for a step-wise guideline.